Visualizing Artikulation

Hello, György

After years of hunting around online, and surely I was looking in all the wrong places, I finally procured the holy grail of electronic music scores, György Ligeti’s Artikulation. Ligeti composed it in 1958 and recorded it at the Studio of Electronic Music of the West German Radio in Cologne. The piece predates the modern analog synthesizers of the late 60’s and early 70’s – the sound sources are a combination of generated sound and tape manipulation.

When you hear it you can’t help but think of R2D2, and yet Artikulation was written 20 years before Star Wars was released. I can’t find any proof that Ben Burtt, the sound designer for Star Wars, was directly inspired by the piece. He used an ARP 2600 and some acoustic sounds for R2D2. But it’s hard for me to imagine that he came up with those sounds without hearing Artikulation, and apparently I’m not alone in that thinking.

Twelve years after Ligeti recorded the piece, Rainer Wehinger created an “aural score” for it. My first introduction to the score was in a music notation class. There were three of us and a teacher in a large room, pouring over various scores week after week. We covered the traditional rules of western notation and we were required to use calligraphy pens to develop our copying skills. Our treble clefs had to look good, our stems had to be the correct length. But we also explored non-traditional 20th century notation, and this score stood out because its unique system was so well thought out and reading the score required no learning curve.

The liner notes for the score provide an explanation for what’s going on in the music:

The piece is called ‘Artikulation’ because in this sense an artificial language is articulated: question and answer, high and low voices, polyglot speaking and interruptions, impulsive outbreaks and humor, charring and whispering.

To realize this in a score, Wehinger used a timeline measured in seconds, and used shapes and colors instead of notes on a staff. He used dots for impulses and combs for noise. He used different colors to represent variations in timbre and pitch.

Notation Diagram

The score and the music still feel fresh despite the long history of electronic music that follows it. I’ve always thought it would make a good motion piece, especially after seeing some incredible music visualizations online. Originally this was going to be the beginning of an endeavor to put the score in motion so that everyone can follow along.

Well, thank god for the internets because someone has done all the hard work for me:


Ligeti – Artikulation
Uploaded by tonicadominante

34 Responses to “Visualizing Artikulation”

  1. very cool. i like ligeti’s music a lot and the visualization is great.

    05/24/08 5:13 am
  2.                 tj milian
  3. Thanks for this. Great video a must watch.

    oh and Reacting to…
    “R2D2, and yet Artikulation was written 20 years before Star Wars was released”

    Please keep in mind that R2D2 existed A long time ago in a galaxy far, far away and word may have spread before the release of the Star Wars documentary of his sounds and may have inspired this piece.

    05/27/08 11:35 pm
  4.                 Hubert
  5. I agree that R2D2’s voice pretty much has to be lifted from this track. Toward the end there’s one section that literally uses the same two notes as one of R2D2’s common expressions. I found this blog entry looking for proof that the inspiration came from Ligeti. Maybe someday we’ll know for sure.

    06/18/08 12:37 am
  6.                 Reynard Seifert
  7. [...] Visualizing Artikulation (via Bad Assembly, da cui è tratta la [...]

    07/24/08 11:18 pm
  8.                 Giavasan » Visualizing Artikulation
  9. I own the original numbered limited edition score. Yes, it’s a beauty and really corresponds well with the music. The original score also comes with a 7 inch record which explains in German how the various sounds were created, plus the full recording.

    07/25/08 7:29 am
  10.                 mark steven brooks
  11. BTW-some of you might be interested in The Center for Visual Music in L.A.

    http://www.centerforvisualmusic.org/

    07/25/08 7:33 am
  12.                 mark steven brooks
  13. Something is wrong here. I saw and heard it with the score in 1970, no later, so the score was not done 20 years later. i believe also i have seen this score attributed to Ligeti.

    07/26/08 2:51 am
  14.                 diogenes
  15. [...] more on Artikulation here [...]

    07/27/08 10:08 am
  16.                 Atikulation Audio Visualization | May Sun Days
  17. Please, visit http://www.sinestesia2009.info and also: MuVi2 price ( visual music 2). Next april 2009 in Granada Spain.

    08/02/08 6:56 am
  18.                 Amparo
  19.                 avraamov
  20. http://www.metaplexity.org/santiago/reArtikulation

    thanks for the post!

    08/06/08 11:54 am
  21.                 santiago
  22. nice clip. music vizualization has an exciting long life ahead!

    08/11/08 2:56 pm
  23.                 escopio
  24. [...] the classical world, partially due to Stanley Kubrick’s use of his music in several films. As Nathan Holloway writes, Ligeti’s “Artikulation” makes you think “of R2D2, and yet Artikulation was [...]

    08/15/08 1:06 pm
  25.                 The Digital Ramble | Visualizing Science - The Moment Blog - NYTimes.com
  26. grererret

    09/03/08 6:06 am
  27.                 jonn
  28. Best Site good looking tubetv jcfmc

    10/09/08 3:13 pm
  29.                 Isulynmv
  30. Thanks funny site free pornhub 3588

    10/09/08 5:57 pm
  31.                 Nkdyhwpa
  32. very best job porntube sites 982

    10/09/08 11:47 pm
  33.                 Uucamkwz
  34. Gloomy tales sextv 1 460

    10/10/08 4:18 am
  35.                 Nuhoaztv
  36. Very Good Site youngporn tube >:OO

    10/10/08 11:17 am
  37.                 Peiybiec
  38. Jonny was here sexyparishilton 72902

    10/16/08 7:37 pm
  39.                 Fhfemqpg
  40. this is be cool 8) sextube 8-((

    10/16/08 10:57 pm
  41.                 Iubmrscf
  42. Best Site good looking x rated rnbb

    10/17/08 1:53 am
  43.                 Kgqlvxju
  44. perfect design thanks gay sex audio hlgoce

    10/17/08 5:35 pm
  45.                 Awqailnq
  46. Very interesting tale florida gay men massage =(

    10/17/08 8:00 pm
  47.                 Jizadbym
  48. very best job free nude chat webcam 5782

    10/18/08 1:34 am
  49.                 Magsopnl
  50. Excellent work, Nice Design http;girls-gone-wild.titsias =-)))

    10/18/08 10:00 am
  51.                 Ueqzkfix
  52. Hello good day free lesbiantube 6990

    10/18/08 10:43 am
  53.                 Pbcfggty
  54. this is be cool 8) naked gay pictures 269743

    10/18/08 12:36 pm
  55.                 Ilaivuiq
  56. When I saw the “aural score” I was instantly reminded of this application: http://www.hyperscore.com/ (Perhaps Rainer Wehinger was their inspiration)

    10/18/08 10:35 pm
  57.                 Kevin Broch
  58. Good crew it’s cool :) Porntv Sex 5883

    11/17/08 1:46 pm
  59.                 Jkwkkcnj
  60. i’m fine good work pornhub porn >:((

    11/18/08 8:32 am
  61.                 Glzleawb
  62. Best Site good looking yobtv %-]

    11/19/08 12:18 pm
  63.                 Ixgcfbym
  64. Excellent work, Nice Design free 100 live xxxtv :OO

    11/21/08 1:05 am
  65.                 Juraipfa
  66. xxxtv 529686

    11/21/08 9:23 am
  67.                 Vldtonny

Respond!